Reading Requires Real Books

This week’s evidence focuses on the fact that real reading requires real books, and it’s not too late to stop the madness of technology substitutes. The latest National Assessment of Educational Progress results are miserable – and we can’t just blame it all on COVID and TikTok. Students spend 8 hours a day on screens, and some schools are succumbing to the siren song of letting tech substitute for reading literacy.

33% of 8th graders are below basic reading skills – the worst result in 32 years. 14% of those students read for pleasure.

English teachers allow more ideas to be represented by images and multimedia, conceding the field to reading real books. 

37% of 12th graders are reading proficiently. 

Some lessons:

Dressing up as characters is not understanding characters.

PowerPoint is not a substitute for writing a coherent essay.

A summary of a novel does not convey the emotion inherent in the text.

I know that the rejoinder to this will be, “We don’t have the time for full novels and essays!” I respect the time demands on teachers. The antidote is not withdrawing from the field of the literacy battles but rather choosing one’s battles more carefully. Four essays a year, with multiple editing and rewriting, is superior to a weekly essay with little respect for teacher feedback. Two novels per year, with close reading and deep discussions, are better than six novels that will be quickly consigned to Cliff Notes or AI content summaries. 

One final note. A friend of mine who is a very distinguished author despaired that her son was going to be an English major, fearing that he would live in poverty in her basement. When he was hired by McKinsey for a six-figure salary, they explained “We can teach you finance, but we can’t teach a finance major to be a good writer.” 

Here’s the link to the article:

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/02/16/opinion/read-books-learning.html

Related Posts

  • Research Wednesday | April 15, 2026

    From PLC Meetings to Instructional Reliability
    Contributing author: Dr. Gregory VanHorn

    This article argues that the persistent struggle of Professional Learning Communities (PLCs) and Multi-Tiered Systems of Support (MTSS) is not a lack of belief, effort, or expertise among educators, but a problem of operating-model design. Drawing carefully from high-reliability organizations—specifically GE Aerospace’s FLIGHT DECK operating model—the author reframes PLCs not as meetings or initiatives, but as Tier 1 instructional engines that must reliably produce improvement through disciplined collaboration and follow-through.

    Read More

  • Research Wednesday | April 8, 2026

    Uncomplicated Grading Reform
    Contributing author: Dr. Emily Freeland

    It is not surprising that in schools and districts, significant grading reform efforts often stall. Not because educators disagree with the need to reconsider current practices, but because the work becomes burdensome and overly complicated. Issues and disagreements arise when monitoring checklists multiply in length; reporting systems grow more complex, and fairness and accuracy give way to compliance.

    Read More

  • Research Wednesday | March 11, 2026

    The Key to Secondary School Success: Getting 9th Grade Right
    Contributing author: Dr. Douglas Reeves

    Kaaron Andrews has studied the relationship between 9th-grade student performance, graduation, and subsequent post-secondary success.  She is the Director of the Center for High School Success. When they increase on-track 9th-grade rates, they are 3-4 times more likely to graduate from high school. It is the single strongest predictor of high school success – more than race, socioeconomic status, or even 8th-grade test scores. She contends that high schools are programmed for disconnection – disconnected from their peer group and from teachers who often have 150 students with whom they struggle to have a relationship.

    Read More