Do You Want to Dig a Ditch or Build a Bridge? Your Grading System Will Answer The Question

November 29, 2016

I recently received a question from a teacher who was concerned that her colleagues, opposed to changes in grading systems, insisted that in the real world, it was essential to get things right the first time.  Therefore, her colleagues claimed, the average, along with draconian punishments for failures, were appropriate grading policies.  

But the “real world” of the 18th century is not where we are preparing students to succeed. Today’s real world requires feedback, acceptance of that feedback, followed by improved performance.  Think of it this way.  The nation is about to spend a trillion dollars on infrastructure improvement.  If you want to use a shovel, you’re fine just as you are – get it right the first time.  If you want to use a machine, like a post-hole digger, be prepared for some feedback and adjustments.  If you want to operate a more complex machine, like an asphalt layer, then be prepared for a lot more feedback and more complex equations before you make the wrong move. If you want to be a surveyor, engineer, or the architect of a bridge, then you’d better be prepared to accept lots and lots of feedback and never, ever, think that you’ll get it right the first time. 

So that’s the real world of the 21st Century.  If you think the real world is “getting it right the first time,” then grab a shovel.  If you think that the real world is gathering lots of feedback, making mistakes, listening to that feedback, and then producing a magnificent road, bridge, or transportation system, then collaborate with your team and change the world, and lock the door on anyone who screams at you that in the real world, you have to do it right the first time.

Purchase Dr. Reeves’ newest books on grading here: Elements of Grading, FAST Grading 

Subscribe to receive our blog updates

 

Related Posts

  • Research Wednesday | April 8, 2026

    Uncomplicated Grading Reform
    Contributing author: Dr. Emily Freeland

    It is not surprising that in schools and districts, significant grading reform efforts often stall. Not because educators disagree with the need to reconsider current practices, but because the work becomes burdensome and overly complicated. Issues and disagreements arise when monitoring checklists multiply in length; reporting systems grow more complex, and fairness and accuracy give way to compliance.

    Read More

  • Research Wednesday | March 11, 2026

    The Key to Secondary School Success: Getting 9th Grade Right
    Contributing author: Dr. Douglas Reeves

    Kaaron Andrews has studied the relationship between 9th-grade student performance, graduation, and subsequent post-secondary success.  She is the Director of the Center for High School Success. When they increase on-track 9th-grade rates, they are 3-4 times more likely to graduate from high school. It is the single strongest predictor of high school success – more than race, socioeconomic status, or even 8th-grade test scores. She contends that high schools are programmed for disconnection – disconnected from their peer group and from teachers who often have 150 students with whom they struggle to have a relationship.

    Read More

  • Research Wednesday | March 4, 2026

    Do Audiobooks Count as Reading?
    Contributing author: Dr. Douglas Reeves

    While surveys indicate that more than 40% of U.S. adults think that listening to a book should not be regarded as genuine reading, Brian Bannon, Chief Librarian of the New York Public Library, disagrees in a November 23, 2025, article.  He notes that while print circulation in the library has remained flat over the past five years, audiobook demand is up 65%.

    Read More